saby says:
What was quite unpalatable was Farhaan Akhtar's singing.. seemed like Farhaan was trying to fulfill his unrequited dream of being a rock star and he got this chance..his singing is quite devoid of range and imagination..though he is barely accepatable in middle octave , he is completely avoidable in higher octaves..I would have imagined that having KK sing for him would have made this movie far more palatable to the ear..and yeah...prachi desai's "ajeeb daastaan hai yeh "" i mean ,you dont let Arjun Ramphal play the guitar in reality..or for that matter Amol Gupte replace Aaamir n TZP just to be real..
I also end to differ with you in Arjun Ramphal's "restrained" acting.. i would tend to think that it is his "lack of capability"..
In my opinion, the dialogues were very mediocre, the direction was listless in terms of storytelling before the intermission, though the tempo picked up a bit after..
Purab was the best among the four..Luke is a terrible miscast(remember the headache scene) ..
But i agree the climax was very good..but then a good restaurant can not be judged by solely on the quality of its tiramisu ..however good it is ..